【研究紹介】The Relationship between Job Stress and Urinary Cytokines in Healthy Nurses: a Cross-Sectional Study
成人・老年看護研究室 福田 広美
Background
Cytokines, such as angiogenin (ANG) and interleukin (IL-8) have been shown to be related to depressive symptoms or inflammatory diseases, like coronary heart diseases, and may be used as stress biomarkers to identify and prevent health problems in nurses. To investigate the relationship between cytokines and nurses’ job stress, urinary ANG or IL-8 were monitored in hospital nurses in Japan.
Methods
The job stresses of 118 healthy female nurses working at general hospitals were evaluated by the Nursing Stress Scale (NSS). The subjects were classified into high and low stress groups according to the stress levels in each NSS subscale. Their subjective psychological states were assessed by the Profile of Mood States Short Form Japanese version (POMS-SFJ). Their urinary ANG, IL-8 and cortisol levels versus subjective psychological states from two groups were compared.
Results & Discussion
The fatigue and depression scores of POMS-SFJ subscales in the present study were higher than those of the general Japanese healthy population (2005). Therefore, the subjects in the present study seemed in a chronic stress state.
Based on the score of total subjects, nurses who were experiencing the pressure of having the responsibility for patients’ life support care (PPLC) were the highest among the possible scores of the NSS subscales. Nurses with high job stresses from PPLC and experienced conflict with physicians had a high level of urinary ANG.
ANG has been implicated in the pathogenesis of inflammatory diseases, such as atherosclerosis and CHD. In this study, the high stress group experiencing conflict with physicians showed not only higher levels of urinary ANG (Figure 1B), but also showed higher POMS-SFJ subscale scores in anger-hostility, fatigue, depression and TMD in comparison to the low stress group (Table 2). Therefore, a nurse with high stress, caused by conflict with physicians, may have a higher risk of inflammatory diseases than a nurse with low stress does.
No significant differences in the POMS subscale scores, with the exception of the fatigue score, were observed among the high and low stress groups experiencing PPLC (Table 2). However, urinary ANG level in the high stress group experiencing PPLC was significantly higher than that in the low stress group (Figure 1A). Therefore, urinary ANG was considered to be a biomarker, which detected the physical distresses of nurses before they are conscious of the negative psychological states such as anger, hostility, and depression in the PPLC.
This study was supported by a grant-in-aid for scientific research from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Science and Technology of Japan.
Fukuda H, Ichinose T, Kusama T,Yoshidome A, Anndow K, Akiyoshi N, Shibamoto T. The Relationship between Job Stress and Urinary Cytokines in Healthy Nurses: a Cross-Sectional
Study. Biological Research For Nursing, Vol 10, No 2, 183-191,
Table 1. Nursing Stress, Urinary Bio-markers Levels and Mood States of the Hospital Female Nurses
All values are expressed as Mean ± SD. POMS = Profile of Mood States Scale (McNair, Lorr, & Droppleman, 1971; Yokoyama, 1990, 2005). NSS = Nursing Stress Scale (Kageyama et al., 2001).a. Urine cytokines and cortisol values were normalized to creatinine.
Table 2. Subjective Mental State by POMS-SFJ Scale in the High and Low Job Stresses Groups in the Each NSS Subscale
NOTE: All values are Mean ± SD. POMS = Profile of Mood States Scale (McNair, Lorr, & Droppleman, 1971; Yokoyama, 1990, 2005). NSS = Nursing Stress Scale (Kageyama, Nishikido, Kobayashi, Oga, & Kawashima, 2001). TMD = Total Mood Disturbance Scores. The subjects were classified into high and low stress groups by a mean split of the NSS subscales scores. The effect of the each stress on mood states was analyzed by ANCOVA with age as the covariate. a. p < 0.05. b. p < 0.01. c. p < 0.001

Figure 1. Effect of each stress in the NSS in urinary ANG and cortisol levels.
Note. All values are Mean ± SD. Urine cytokines and cortisol values were normalized to creatinine. Data were analyzed by ANCOVA with age as the covariate.
In A. High stress group, n = 83. Low stress group, n = 35.
In B. High stress group, n = 59. Low stress group, n = 57.
In C High stress group, n = 82. Low stress group, n = 36.
* p < 0 .05.

携帯サイト

